converter connected to a PMSG wind turbine can regulate DC-link voltage more effectively than a passive
rectifier, while Rajaei et al. further showed that Vienna-rectifier topologies reduce switching and conduction
losses for low-power PM-based wind energy conversion systems; in the same vein, Annisa et al. simplified
firing-angle generation for a three-phase controlled rectifier through a Simulink-based cosine-comparator
gate-control logic, Acikgoz et al. combined a type-2 fuzzy neural network with artificial-bee-colony
optimization to regulate the DC-link voltage of a three-phase PWM rectifier under unbalanced supply and
regenerative-mode conditions, and Li et al. proposed a model-predictive direct power control method that
reduces the computational burden of PWM rectifier control without sacrificing regulation accuracy.
[15-19]
A
third group of studies investigated proportional-integral (PI) control applied at the DC-link or rectifier output;
Bouafia et al. combined fuzzy logic and PI control for direct power control of a three-phase PWM rectifier to
regulate the output voltage; Sanchis and Peñarrocha-Alós proposed an experimental step-response-based
tuning method for PI controllers; and Zhou et al. reported that a well-tuned PI controller can maintain a near-
sinusoidal input current with low distortion while preserving system power-factor reliability.
[20-22]
Furthermore, Nurwati et al. reinforced that discrete PI control in PWM rectifiers can significantly enhance
system performance.
[23]
Beyond rectifier-specific applications, similar trial-and-error and optimization-based
PI tuning approaches have proven effective for other power-electronic converters that supply wind and
renewable-energy loads; Chincholkar et al. introduced a normalized-error PI controller to overcome
saturation limitations in a DC-DC buck converter; Uc et al. validated PI-gain optimization using local-and-
global search algorithms on a DC-DC boost converter; and Mrabet et al. compared trial-and-error Kp/Ki
optimization against metaheuristic tuning for a wind-energy MPPT controller, reinforcing that trial-and-error
PI tuning remains a practical and sufficiently accurate baseline for this class of system.
[24-26]
A fourth group
examined rectifier control performance under variations in speed, input voltage, and load; Shwetha and
Guruswamy applied a whale-optimization-algorithm-tuned PI controller to a three-phase PWM rectifier and
achieved a rise time of 0.0126 s, a settling time of 0.06 s, and a DC voltage ripple below 3%, whereas Alzahrani
compared controlled and uncontrolled rectifiers for low-power wind turbines and reported that fully
controlled rectifiers provide a wider regulation range under varying firing angles at the cost of additional
control-circuit complexity.
[27,28]
Finally, a fifth group of studies validated their proposed control strategies
across multiple platforms, combining MATLAB/Simulink simulation with either circuit-level software or
physical hardware testing to confirm consistency between numerical and experimental results.
[22,27,28]
However, most of these studies were conducted under highly stable source conditions and do not accurately
reflect the characteristics of wind power generation at low and variable wind speeds.
1.2. Research gap
Previous research has developed various rectifier topologies and control methods for wind energy conversion
systems based on permanent magnet synchronous generators (PMSGs).
[29-31]
However, studies on the effects of
the duty cycle-varying PWM on the DC output voltage and voltage ripple under open-loop conditions,
especially across input voltages representing changes in the wind speed, still need further investigation. In
addition, the influence of resistive (R) and resistive–inductive (R–L) load characteristics, as well as the
effectiveness of proportional–integral (PI) controllers in improving DC voltage stability and reducing ripples
compared with uncontrolled conditions, requires quantitative evaluation of the same rectifier configuration.
Studies integrating system-level simulation in MATLAB/Simulink and circuit-level simulation in Proteus
should also be developed to provide a more comprehensive performance analysis. Therefore, this study
evaluates PWM-based three-phase rectifiers with PI controllers across various input voltages, duty cycles, and
R and R–L loads by comparing open-loop and closed-loop performance. This study's main contribution is a
quantitative evaluation of DC voltage regulation and voltage-ripple reduction across two simulation
platforms, providing a basis for developing and experimentally validating low-speed PMSG-based wind
energy conversion systems.
1.3. Proposed solution
To address these gaps, in this study, a PI-controlled PWM three-phase rectifier intended for a low-speed PMSG
wind energy system is designed. The control variable is the DC output voltage of the rectifier, which is
regulated by adjusting the PWM duty cycle applied to the six MOSFET switches on the basis of the error
between the reference voltage and the measured DC output. The system is first analyzed under open-loop
conditions with manually set duty cycles of 30%, 50%, 74%, and 95% to characterize the rectifier's inherent
behavior and subsequently evaluated under closed-loop PI control at three-phase input voltages of 48 V and
36 V, which are used as representative operating points for higher- and lower-wind-speed conditions,
respectively (see Section 2.2 regarding the fixed-voltage-source representation of the PMSG input), rather
than being derived from a calibrated wind-speed-to-voltage PMSG model. Both resistive (R) and resistive-
inductive (R-L) loads are tested to evaluate the influence of load characteristics on system performance.
System-level control design and PI tuning are performed in MATLAB/Simulink, while circuit-level