years old) and 25 naturally regenerating plots, set against 17 benchmark rainforest plots, revealed that active
restoration recovered 82% of the canopy cover, 49% of the tree species density and 47% of the aboveground
carbon storage relative to the gap between natural regeneration and the benchmark forest, whereas the
compositional similarity recovered only 14%.
[22]
The benefits of planting for canopy cover and late-successional
species were greater for more isolated fragments.
[22]
These results are consistent with the global message that
the restoration method should be matched to the landscape context: natural regeneration is preferable when
seed sources are close and disturbance is low, whereas weed control and native planting can be justified in
isolated, invaded fragments.
[16,20]
National restoration targets in India are expressed mainly as areas brought
under restoration; outcome-based monitoring would allow evidence such as that from the Western Ghats to be
scaled up and compared across approaches.
[13]
3.3 Carbon storage and climate mitigation
Forests are major carbon sinks. An assessment of inventory and remote-sensing data revealed a persistent net
sink in the world's forests, in which tropical regrowth and temperate and boreal forests offset gross emissions
from deforestation.
[28]
Natural forest regrowth is particularly effective: mapped estimates of carbon
accumulation suggest that the regrowth of natural forests can sequester large quantities of carbon, with rates
varying with climate, soils and prior land use, and that default IPCC rates underestimate aboveground carbon
accumulation by approximately 32% on average.
[18]
These maps were constructed from 13,112 field
measurements and show more than 100-fold variation in accumulation rates across the globe during the first
30 years of regrowth.
[18]
Complementing this, it has been argued that restoring natural forests is the most
reliable route to long-term carbon removal because natural and mixed forests store more carbon over time than
monoculture plantations do and provide additional benefits.
[7]
Carbon outcomes of agroforestry and plantations
are more variable. In India, the modeled carbon sequestration potential of existing agroforestry areas averaged
0.21 Mg C ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹ across 26 districts in ten states, with an average of approximately 19 trees ha⁻¹ on farmer
fields and large differences among systems and regions.
[23]
This is lower per hectare than the rates reported for
natural regrowth, such as 3.05 Mg C ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹, over the first 20 years in Neotropical secondary forests, although
the two estimates come from different methods and are not directly comparable.
[17]
Agroforestry stores carbon
on productive farmland where forest regrowth is not an option, and it also supplies food and income. Carbon
uptake can be rapid during early growth but depends on species, rotation length and the fate of harvested wood,
and the permanence of carbon uptake is generally lower in planted forests than in natural or mixed forests.
[7]
These outcomes vary with species composition, plantation structure, management and site conditions (Table
2).
Climate benefits are, however, conditional. Credible mitigation depends on permanence, additionality,
avoidance of leakage and accurate accounting; forests cannot compensate for continued fossil-fuel emissions
and must be seen as complementary to rapid emission reductions.
[29]
Restoring trees on naturally nonforest
ecosystems, such as grasslands and savannas, may yield minimal carbon gains while damaging unique
biodiversity, changing water balance and altering albedo.
[8]
Table 4 summarizes key quantitative findings from
the literature on the biodiversity and carbon outcomes of forest restoration, including numerical estimates,
units and study context (region and sample size) wherever the cited studies report them. A comparison of the
five approaches across the four decision criteria is shown in Fig. 2. It is a semiquantitative, expert-judgment
summary based on a qualitative synthesis of the studies reviewed, using the criteria and scoring basis set out in
Table 1. It is not an empirical measurement and should be read separately from the quantitative evidence in
Table 4.
3.3.1 Scoring basis for Figure 2
In Fig. 2, each approach was rated from 1 (low) to 5 (high) on four criteria. Carbon uptake refers to the rate of
aboveground carbon accumulation and storage over approximately the first 30 years after intervention relative
to the other approaches; long-term permanence is discussed above and is not scored. Biodiversity refers to the
expected recovery of native species richness, composition and habitat structure relative to those of the reference
forest. Livelihood benefits refer to direct food, fodder, fuel, timber, income and employment benefits for local
people. Cost-effectiveness refers to the expected ecological and climate benefits per unit of cost, taking
establishment, maintenance and protection costs into account. The scores are relative rankings among the five
approaches, not absolute measurements. They were assigned by comparing the evidence in Sections 3.1–3.3
(Tables 2 and 4), and they represent typical tendencies that may differ for individual projects depending on
species composition, management and site conditions. Table 1 provides the basis for each score.
3.4 Contribution to sustainable development
Restoration contributes to development through multiple pathways: climate action (SDG 13), life on land (SDG
15), poverty reduction and decent work (SDGs 1 and 8), food security (SDG 2) and clean water (SDG 6). The
benefits of restoring priority areas can increase; a global prioritization study estimated that restoring 15% of